Wednesday, March 7, 2012

Argument Outline

Question: How does immigration affect the United States and the flow of money and jobs within?

Thesis: The amounts of immigrants combined with the benefits they receive living in America can adversely affect our economy. Although, the positive outcomes can be seen if we understand their perspective and give aid to those who need it resulting in the agreement of both sides.

I.               Immigrants tend to take the jobs others don’t want or cant fill simply because of their need for income and due to the fact that it will still be better than their current conditions.
a.     Our economy therefore can flourish if we are able to get people into jobs and providing for their family.  Some places without people and with economies collapsing simply need these people to get themselves back on their feet.
b.     “People know that people are migrating to Texas, which means that people know that nominal spending flows in Texas will increase at a healthy clip. Since that confidence in growth exists, people keep building homes and shopping malls to capture that spending. Hospitals keep expanding. Schools add new facilities rather than closing existing ones. And Texas, famously, has led the nation in job growth.”  (Gingrich)
II.             Immigrants also are able to help Americans and their income and may even increase our wages and help us get better jobs and have more to choose from. By deporting them, we would just be losing money but by letting them stay and work with us, we are able to prosper because of the added help and strength of those willing to work to support their families.
a.     “The real wages of less-skilled newly legalized workers would increase by roughly $4,405 per year, while higher-skilled workers would see their income increase $6,185 per year. The wages of native-born high-skill and low-skill U.S. workers also increase modestly under comprehensive immigration reform because the “wage floor” rises for all workers.” (Hinojosa-Ojeda)
b.     Mass deportation would only cost us more money because of the fact that we would have to provide means of transportation since we are kicking them out.
c.      On the other hand, sometimes immigrants succeed in taking most jobs available and put others out of work. In this case, though, we experience competition and that can only be healthy for our economy.
d.     If an immigrant holds a job and then has been deported, they then will lose their work and cost the firm money in filling the void or doing without for a while.
III.           If we eliminate immigration all together then there will be even more incentive for illegals to come here. If we allow them to do it legally and within our boundaries and rules then our country can process smoothly.
a.     If we higher them for cheap labor, business may have more time and money to get other things taken care of. When we have them do these jobs then we are free to move on to other jobs and services and expand the economy even more.
b.     It is not necessarily the fault of the immigrants that they were born into a country that struggled and want to come better their chances in the United States. Instead of kicking them out without a fair assessment we should give them the same treatment we give those who live here; a fair chance to make a life for themselves and family.

Conclusion: Immigration, no matter where from and how much help is needed, should be tolerated in the sense that these people are not stealing our country, they are simply just helping us out. Let them take the cheap labor jobs and let them compete for even better jobs if they want. The American people can be lazy and need some incentive to fight for their money. The economy is our main focus and most of the immigrants fleeing here can do nothing but help. We need to enforce the same laws and rules and try our best to get them on their feet just as we do with ourselves.

No comments:

Post a Comment